Skip to main content

GitHub Copilot Code Review

AI-powered code reviews using GitHub Copilot to analyze pull requests and suggest improvements.

Overview​

GitHub Copilot integration provides intelligent code reviews that analyze your changes and provide actionable feedback.

Prerequisites​

  • GitHub Copilot extension installed
  • Active GitHub Copilot subscription
  • Pull request open in C# Dev Tools

Starting a Copilot Review​

From Pull Request View​

  1. Open a pull request
  2. Click "Review with Copilot" button
  3. Copilot analyzes the changes
  4. Review appears in webview

Review Process​

Copilot analyzes:

  • Code changes and diffs
  • Potential bugs
  • Code quality issues
  • Best practice violations
  • Security concerns
  • Performance implications

Review Insights​

Code Quality​

Copilot checks for:

  • Readability: Clear naming, structure
  • Maintainability: Complexity, duplication
  • Consistency: Coding standards
  • Documentation: Comments, XML docs

Potential Issues​

Identifies:

  • Bugs: Logic errors, null references
  • Security: Vulnerabilities, unsafe code
  • Performance: Inefficient patterns
  • Resource leaks: Disposables, connections

Best Practices​

Suggests improvements for:

  • SOLID principles: Design patterns
  • DRY: Reducing duplication
  • .NET conventions: Framework guidelines
  • Async/await: Proper async usage

Review Comments​

Inline Suggestions​

Copilot provides:

  • Line-specific feedback
  • Code snippets for fixes
  • Alternative approaches
  • Explanation of issues

Severity Levels​

Comments are categorized:

  • Critical: Must fix before merge
  • Warning: Should address
  • Suggestion: Consider improving
  • Info: FYI, optional

Acting on Feedback​

Accepting Suggestions​

  1. Review Copilot's feedback
  2. Apply suggested changes
  3. Commit improvements
  4. Request new review

Discussing Suggestions​

  1. Reply to Copilot comments
  2. Ask for clarification
  3. Provide context
  4. Explain decisions

Integration with Reviews​

Combined with Human Reviews​

Copilot reviews complement human reviews:

  • Copilot catches common issues
  • Humans focus on business logic
  • Faster overall review process
  • Higher code quality

Review Workflow​

  1. Create pull request
  2. Run Copilot review
  3. Address critical issues
  4. Request human review
  5. Address final feedback
  6. Merge when approved

Benefits​

Faster Reviews​

  • Immediate automated feedback
  • Catch issues early
  • Reduce review cycles
  • Speed up development

Consistent Quality​

  • Enforces best practices
  • Catches common mistakes
  • Applies same standards
  • Improves team consistency

Learning Tool​

  • Understand why changes suggested
  • Learn best practices
  • Improve coding skills
  • Share knowledge

Limitations​

AI Limitations​

Copilot may:

  • Miss context-specific issues
  • Suggest overly generic fixes
  • Not understand business logic
  • Require clarification

Best Used For​

Copilot excels at:

  • Syntax and style issues
  • Common bug patterns
  • Best practice violations
  • Code smell detection

Not a Replacement​

Copilot doesn't replace:

  • Human judgment
  • Business logic review
  • Architecture decisions
  • Domain expertise

Configuration​

Review Settings​

Configure Copilot reviews:

  1. Open extension settings
  2. Search "copilot review"
  3. Adjust:
    • Review depth
    • Suggestion verbosity
    • Auto-review on PR creation

Best Practices​

  • Run Copilot review before human review
  • Address critical issues first
  • Use as learning opportunity
  • Combine with tests
  • Don't blindly accept all suggestions
  • Provide feedback to Copilot

Tips​

Effective Reviews​

  • Review small PRs more effectively
  • Provide context in PR description
  • Include tests in PR
  • Document complex changes
  • Respond to all feedback

Getting Better Suggestions​

  • Write clear commit messages
  • Include PR description
  • Link to issues
  • Add comments for complex code
  • Use descriptive names

Troubleshooting​

Copilot Not Available​

If Copilot review unavailable:

  1. Check Copilot extension installed
  2. Verify subscription active
  3. Ensure PR is loaded
  4. Restart VS Code

Poor Suggestions​

If suggestions aren't helpful:

  1. Provide more context in PR
  2. Add code comments
  3. Improve PR description
  4. Split large PRs
  5. Include test coverage

Review Failed​

If review fails:

  1. Check internet connection
  2. Verify Copilot status
  3. Try smaller PR
  4. Check PR file count
  5. Retry review